Bold claim: the playoff picture hinges on two heated bubble debates, and this week’s outcomes could tilt the entire field. The first debate matters most for this year’s selection, because Alabama, Notre Dame, or Miami could all surge if they reach the tournament, especially given likely matchups against Texas A&M and Oklahoma. The committee’s recent commentary suggests Notre Dame is earning strong support; their 10-game win streak and the quality of Marcus Freeman’s squad have often been highlighted more for their on-field performance than traditional résumé notes. That pattern hints that enough voters will rank Notre Dame high enough to secure a playoff berth, possibly even earning a home game over a Sooner team whose best win has dimmed since Atlanta.
On the other hand, Alabama isn’t out of it yet in my view, even if that would surprise me personally. Their metrics and victories still outpace Miami’s, which makes them a natural buffer between the two teams’ head-to-head result—much like they’ve functioned all season.
A separate, notable question surrounds Duke. The Blue Devils didn’t crack any Top 25 in the committee’s latest snapshot, and it would be extraordinary to see a five-loss ACC champion placed above James Madison, which went 12–1 and was ranked No. 25 just days earlier. The committee would require a majority of voters to favor Duke over James Madison, and that seems unlikely given the metrics.
If Duke’s ascent somehow happens and a Power Four conference lands outside the CFP, the ripple effects could reshape the playoff’s structure in the years ahead. Commissioners already pushed back the format-decision deadline for 2026–27 until after this season’s national championship, a gap that could be exploited by the Big Ten or SEC to push for expansion or new seeding rules.
This weekend’s conference championships were audacious and may prove to have the deepest long-term impact on the playoff landscape.
Rankings snapshot (illustrative, not the official bracket):
First ranking batch:
1. Indiana
2. Ohio State
3. Georgia
4. Texas Tech
5. Oregon
6. Mississippi
7. Texas A&M
8. Oklahoma
9. Notre Dame
10. Alabama
11. Tulane
12. James Madison
First out: Miami
Second out: Texas
Second ranking batch:
1. Indiana
2. Ohio State
3. Georgia
4. Texas Tech
5. Oregon
6. Mississippi
7. Texas A&M
8. Oklahoma
9. Miami
10. Notre Dame
11. Tulane
12. James Madison
First out: Alabama
Second out: Texas
Further College Football content from Sports Illustrated
Listen: SI’s college sports podcast Others Receiving Votes, on Apple and Spotify, or watch on SI’s YouTube channel.
